Motley Moose – Archive

Since 2008 – Progress Through Politics

BYORB: Bring Your Own (Reusable) Bottle

Today is the first day in a ban on on-campus sales of bottled water at the University of Vermont.

When students at the University of Vermont resume classes on the snow-covered Burlington campus Monday, something will be missing: bottled water. UVM is the latest university to ban on-campus sales of bottled water.

At UVM, students can get water for their reusable bottles at specially designed campus fill-up locations. The ban was the result of a campaign started by former student Mikayla McDonald to not only reduce waste but to protect our natural resources:


“Bottled water is a symbol of our culture’s obsession with commodifying things that should be public trust resources,” she says.

(The web site Ban the Bottle has more information about bans that are in effect and planned).

One unintentional landfill created by plastic dumping is the Great Pacific Garbage Patch:

The Great Pacific Garbage Patch, also described as the Pacific Trash Vortex, is a gyre of marine litter in the central North Pacific Ocean located roughly between 135°W to 155°W and 35°N and 42°N. The patch extends over an indeterminate area, with estimates ranging very widely depending on the degree of plastic concentration used to define the affected area.

The Patch is characterized by exceptionally high concentrations of pelagic plastics, chemical sludge, and other debris that have been trapped by the currents of the North Pacific Gyre.

According to an article from the University of Melbourne, 90% of the debris is plastic:

There are five major gyres in the Indian, Atlantic and Pacific oceans, each with their own floating mats of rubbish, but it is expected that many more of these litter flotillas occur in smaller current systems across the world.

● At least 80% of this rubbish originates on land, washing out to sea via stormwater drains or from landfill located near the sea. The rest is discarded from ships and oil platforms.

● 90% of the debris is plastic.

American marine and atmospheric scientists predicted the presence of these swirling vortexes of rubbish in 1988. The Great Pacific Garbage Patch was discovered in 1997 by oceanographer Captain Charles Moore, who came across by accident it while travelling home from a TransPacific yacht race. Moore remarked that he sailed through the floating rubbish for more than a week.

In a not-at-all-unexpected development, some people see bans on plastic bottles as a direct assault on their liberties (“Patrick Henry!!!1!!”). Regarding a ban being promoted for Concord MA:

The ban is the result of the efforts of Jean Hill, an 85-year-old Concord grandmother who took up the campaign to ban plastic water bottles after hearing of “floating islands of plastic as big as the United States” in the Pacific Ocean.[…]

Truth be told, Hill sounds more like the British, telling us what to drink — and what to drink it out of. She was finally able to vanquish the enemy — the dreaded plastic bottle — at Town Meeting after twice seeing it go down to defeat.

“People should have the freedom to buy a legal product in the town they live in,” group member Robin Garrison, has been quoted as saying.

Patrick Henry couldn’t have said it better.

(I hope that is snark … but I fear that it is not).

Here is what I use, purchased for $9 at my local Shopko:



● Single wall, BPA-free cold beverage bottle

● Leak-proof sealing lid

● Twist body to add ice cubs, lemons or limes

● Soft grip body

● Trendy colored grip

● 16.9-oz. capacity

BPA-free? Check.

Leak-proof? Check.

Comfortable grip? Check.

Blue? Check.

Trendy? Checkity check check check.

And for the record, destroying our common planet is NOT your unalienable right, Mr. GiveMePlasticBottlesOrGiveMeDeath.

It is actually our moral obligation to protect the environment and give future generations a safe and healthy place to live.  


28 comments

  1. fcvaguy

    I’m very much enjoying the high level of attention amongst my neighbors with respect to protecting our environment. Since I moved here, I’m astounded by how much of my trash I’ve been able to commit to recycling – approximately 3/4 overall!! One of the keys is exactly what your diary is about – plastic.

  2. pittiepat

    or Colorado.  I’ll do a google search.  When traveling, most recently between Columbia and Colorado Springs, a 12 hour drive which I make non-stop, I buy 2 bottles of water.  I freeze one to put in the cooler and the other to sip on during the drive.  The frozen one gets thawed and lives in the frig getting refilled repeatedly.  The tired-out bottle ends up in a recycling bin at one of the local organic food stores.

  3. Avilyn

    the legislature was talking about banning plastic bags, or adding a charge per bag like 5 cents.  Cue the whining from the usual suspects; no idea if it’ll actually pass.  I hope it does, since similar bans have been shown to reduce waste in the towns that enacted them.  Personally, I’ve been using Flip and Tumble bags for the last month or so, and they’re really good – fold up small for carrying (easy to always keep one in a pocket), hold up well to washing (unlike many of the store reuseable bags), and I haven’t touched plastic bags since I started using them.  win-win-win.

  4. jlms qkw

    it seems to be very hard for my children to stick to putting water in them.  also, my daughter gloms on to the prettiest one available.  

    i also re-use other containers as they are available, before they go into the recyling bin.  

    okay, so we have a constitutional right to destroy the earth and its oceans.  let’s give the wingnuts that.  

    maybe we don’t need to exercise all of our constitutional rights all the time.  ?  

    or maybe there isn’t a constitutional right to destroy the earth?  

  5. earicicle

    Once you start drinking water stored in glass, you will never go back to plastic of any kind. Since my cancer diagnosis, I wanted to purge all vestiges of plastic food & beverage storage from my life. I drink tons of water, and have a faucet-mounted filter for the sink tap. I switched to glass pitchers for storing cold water in the fridge. I found some terrific Italian-made 2 liter pitchers from Frigoverre that are practically bulletproof and don’t take up much space. (I keep two in the fridge at all times.)

    For bottled water, Lifefactory makes thick bottles covered with silicone outer sleeves to protect the glass. (They also make baby bottles & sippy cups.) I’ve had three bottles for about two years now–I bang ’em around quite a bit and there is nary a chip.

    I promise I’ll learn how to embed Moose links soon. For now:

    Lifefactory: http://www.lifefactory.com/

    Frigoverre Jug: Its technical name is ‘Bormioli Rocco Frigoverre Jug with Hermetic Lid, 2 liters.’ Google any permutation thereof, and you should find lots of options. It shouldn’t run you more than $15. I got mine at Amazon.com.

  6. earicicle

    and I don’t want to toss it in the bottom of a boat as I’m paddling. So I also have a variety of lightweight stainless steel bottles for refilling, too.

  7. melvin

    as membership premiums. Right now Food and Water Watch will give you one for a $15 donation. Mine is from Oceana.

Comments are closed.