Motley Moose – Archive

Since 2008 – Progress Through Politics

Casting Doubt: Birthers In The News

My family isn’t the sharpest set of tools in the shed. They’re often one suit short of a full deck of cards. So it didn’t surprise me when my grandmother came to me yesterday very upset saying she wanted to know why no one told her Obama wasn’t born in the United States when she voted for him last year.

“If I had to know he was unqualified, I wouldn’t have voted,” she said.

I told her it was a lie, and why did she think it was true?

“Well Donald Trump says it’s true and it’s all over the news,” she said.

All over the news.  

My grandmother asked me because she saw the story on ABC and since I used to work there, she thought I would know about the story, or something.

I noticed later on that Jake Tapper, who has been covering the “story” tweeted this a week or so again;

Tweeps saying we shouldn’t cover the birther crap, I hear ya, but what is the responsibility of media if untruths persist and if public figures comment on the nonsense? It’s a double-edged sword but as long as report the facts I think we need wade in.

The media’s responsibility should be to not allow people, even public figures, who keep speaking untruths to be able to speak them louder. You’re giving them a soapbox, regardless of whether or not you’re debunking them.

The problem, Jake (who I know on an acquantance level from my time at ABC) is by allowing Donald Trump and others to express this crap on national TV, you are festering doubt in the minds of the public. You’re not going to change the minds of those who believe birther bullshit, you’re going to take people who don’t know about it, like my grandmother, and allow her to think that the claims have some merit. Someone like Donald Trump, whom she may not like but recognizes as a smart human being, is saying something, why would it be a lie? She sees that and thinks “maybe it’s true.”

If Paris Hilton said tomorrow that Jews caused 9/11, you wouldn’t wade into the story and give her a soapbox, you would call her an idiot and an anti-Semite, declare her celebrity status revoked and move on. You wouldn’t do a “he said, she said” debate. You’d shut her up.

By talking about this nonsense, you’re giving merit to it. People like my grandmother think if something makes the news, it has merit.

Ignore the birthers.  


9 comments

  1. HappyinVT

    general is that no one pushes back.  The Atlantic, I believe it was, talked to a guy who had done research into Obama’s birth certificate to see what Trump’s “investigators” are likely to find in Hawaii.  The short answer is, “nothing.”  There is no smoking gun.

    Trump trots out the tired lie that Obama’s grandmother said Obama was born in Kenya.  No one bothers to mention that the grandmother was talking through an interpreter on the phone and that the interpreter didn’t even speak the same dialect.  And, that the interpreter made the distinction later in the conversation that the grandmother (actually step) was talking about Barack Sr.

    Yet the media reports what Trump and others say without actually calling them on any of it.  That’s what ticks me off.

    Then you have that dumbass b*tch in California who sends a racist piece of shit email to some friends with Obama and his parents as monkeys while questioning his birth and is excused by some as being “serious” about the president’s birth.  Fuck her and her questions.  If the media did half it’s job they would have laid the Birther stuff to rest and this woman would resign.

  2. HappyinVT

    Likely either she realized Arizonians wouldn’t qualify and/or she doubted it was Constitutional.  Or she figured Arizona didn’t need to look like an idiot state trying to keep the current POTUS off the ballot

    “I do not support designating one person as the gatekeeper to the ballot for a candidate, which could lead to arbitrary or politically motivated decisions,” Brewer said in her veto message, the Associated Press reports. Brewer herself is a former Arizona Secretary of State.

    “In addition, I never imagined being presented with a bill that could require candidates for president of the greatest and most powerful nation on Earth to submit their early baptismal circumcision certificates’ among other records to the Arizona secretary of state. This is a bridge too far.” http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo…  

    Whatever the reason, honestly, I give her some credit.  She could have taken no action and essentially washed her hands of the issue.  But she made a decision and put it on the record so to speak.

Comments are closed.